Comments written on other sites from November 2009

A Whole Lotta Nothing: Adventures in brain tumors: part one of many

Take care Matt. Thinking of you here in London. Phil.

On 15 November 2009. Permalink

What I should have said at playful on Flickr - Photo Sharing!

What kind of games require not much attention for not much time?

On 19 November 2009. Permalink

Progress on Flickr - Photo Sharing!

Congratulations everyone!

Phew, such a simple looking thing…

On 23 November 2009. Permalink

Ruby Pseudo Wants a Word: Chair in space…

It’s not really “turning the commercial into an art form”, more “copying an art form into a commercial”.


It’s a copy of an idea by an artist, Simon Faithfull, from 2004. Apparently he was “involved” in the commercial but the fact that few people know it’s a re-make of an idea by someone other than the ad agency doesn’t make this much better.

I guess some of what you say still holds — regardless who came up with the idea, using something like this as an advert is unusual. But what people are going to be impressed by is the original idea itself, regardless of whether it’s an advert or an anoymous clip on YouTube. And the person who came up with that gets no credit.

It’s not a “feat of awe inspiring ingenuity and creativity” on the part of the “company”. They’re just good at picking which existing ideas to copy.

On 25 November 2009. Permalink